Skip to main content
Carbon CycleScripps Institution of Oceanography· 6 min read· in Science

Thirty-Year Dataset Reveals Ocean Carbon Absorption Accelerating While Land Sink Stalls

The global ocean has absorbed an escalating share of human carbon emissions since 1990, while the capacity of terrestrial ecosystems to sequester carbon has stagnated. The divergence challenges prevailing climate models that rely on a growing land sink to offset fossil fuel combustion.

By Nicolas Laurent

Share this story

Listen

Earth's oceans have absorbed an accelerating share of human carbon dioxide emissions over the past three decades, masking a critical failure on land. While marine waters continuously expanded their carbon uptake, the world's forests and soils stopped increasing their absorption capacity.[2]

The divergence between the two natural buffers emerges from a 30-year dataset published Thursday in the journal Science. Researchers analyzed atmospheric oxygen and carbon dioxide measurements collected globally since 1990 to track where human emissions ultimately settle.[1][2]

The findings reveal that the global ocean absorbed an average of 2.8 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide annually between 1990 and 2019. That marine drawdown accounted for approximately 35 percent of all fossil fuel emissions produced during the 30-year window.[2][4]

"Without the land and ocean absorbing half the CO2 from fossil fuel emissions, we would be living on a very different planet," said Eric Morgan, a project scientist at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography and the study's lead author. "But these sinks can't be observed directly."[2]

The fragile terrestrial buffer

In sharp contrast to the strengthening marine sink, terrestrial ecosystems exhibited no notable long-term growth in net carbon absorption. Forests, soils, and related biomes sequestered an average of 1 billion metric tons of carbon annually, representing just 13 percent of total emissions.[2][4]

The marine carbon sink has continuously expanded since 1990, while the terrestrial sink has failed to keep pace.

Rather than following a steady upward trajectory alongside escalating emissions, the net land sink displayed massive decadal swings in operational strength. The terrestrial buffer reached its maximum capacity in the decade centered on 2009 and has generally declined in the years since.[2][4]

The stagnation directly challenges prevailing climate models, which widely assume that a natural land sink will continue growing. Those simulations predict that rising atmospheric carbon dioxide and nitrogen deposition should continuously fertilize plant growth, locking away more carbon in terrestrial biomass.[3][4]

"It was very surprising to see how the net land sink has not kept pace with rising CO2 levels," Morgan said. "Our data underscore that the land sink may be pretty fragile, contradicting the assumption that nature will simply scale up to handle our output."[4]

The failure of the land sink to expand means that terrestrial ecosystems are not providing the escalating buffer that policymakers have counted on. If forests and soils cannot absorb a proportional share of rising emissions, the atmosphere will accumulate greenhouse gases faster than projected.[2][3]

Measuring the invisible

Because carbon sinks cannot be weighed or measured directly, the research team had to track the gases left behind in the atmosphere. The analysis relied on the Scripps O2 Program, an initiative founded in 1989 by geoscientist Ralph Keeling to monitor atmospheric oxygen.[4][5]

The program maintains a network of 10 remote sampling sites stretching along the Pacific Ocean from the high Arctic to the South Pole. Researchers collect regular air samples in glass flasks and ship them back to laboratories in California for high-precision analysis.[2][4]

The Scripps O2 Program relies on a network of remote sampling sites stretching from the Arctic to the South Pole.

By measuring the exact ratio of oxygen to carbon dioxide in these global air samples, scientists can distinguish between marine and terrestrial carbon uptake. Plants release oxygen when they absorb carbon, while the ocean's physical absorption of carbon dioxide does not produce an oxygen signature.[2][3]

Andrew Watson, a co-author from the University of Exeter, emphasized the extreme technical difficulty of the multi-decade monitoring effort. The specialized instruments must detect microscopic fluctuations in atmospheric composition against a massive, constantly shifting background volume of ambient global gases.[3]

"Atmospheric oxygen measurements at the parts per million precision needed for this work are incredibly difficult to do," Watson said. "But the payoff is a unique understanding of the workings of the whole Earth system and how it is responding to human-caused change."[3]

The cost of marine absorption

While the land sink stalled, the marine carbon sink expanded continuously over the 30-year study period. The ocean's absorption capacity grew at a measurable rate of 0.63 billion metric tons of carbon per year for every decade since 1990.[2][4]

This continuous expansion established the ocean as the dominant sink for carbon dioxide, preventing a much steeper rise in global temperatures. However, the sheer volume of dissolved gas is fundamentally altering the chemistry of the marine environment.[2][5]

When carbon dioxide dissolves in seawater, it forms carbonic acid, which steadily lowers the pH of the ocean. This process, known as ocean acidification, degrades the marine habitats that support coral reefs, shellfish, and the broader aquatic food web.[2][4]

Between 1990 and 2019, the ocean absorbed 35 percent of fossil fuel emissions, compared to just 13 percent by land ecosystems.

The chemical shift also reduces the ocean's baseline buffering capacity over time. As seawater becomes more acidic, its natural ability to absorb additional carbon dioxide from the atmosphere begins to diminish, threatening the very mechanism that has protected the climate so far.[3][5]

The international research team included scientists from the Max Planck Institute for Biogeochemistry, the National Center for Atmospheric Research, and the National Institute for Environmental Studies in Japan. Their combined analysis confirms that the ocean is currently bearing the brunt of human emissions.[2][5]

Thermal stratification limits

Even though the ocean sink has grown stronger in recent decades, physical limits dictate that it cannot accelerate indefinitely. As global temperatures climb, the surface waters of the ocean are absorbing massive amounts of trapped atmospheric heat.[3][4]

Warmer seawater naturally retains less dissolved gas than cold water, directly decreasing its baseline solubility for carbon dioxide. This fundamental thermodynamic constraint means that a heating ocean will eventually become less efficient at pulling greenhouse gases out of the air.[3][4]

Furthermore, rising surface temperatures actively increase the thermal stratification of the entire water column. This strengthening density barrier severely reduces the rate at which warm, buoyant surface waters can mix with the cold, heavier layers of the deep ocean.[3][4]

That mechanical mixing process is essential for transporting dissolved carbon into the deep abyssal waters, where it can be safely locked away from the atmosphere for centuries. If stratification slows this circulation, the surface ocean will saturate with carbon much faster.[3][4]

Illustration: Rising surface temperatures increase thermal stratification, which prevents carbon-rich surface waters from mixing into the deep ocean.

"These results represent decades of work by a small community of very dedicated scientists who make those observations," Watson noted, warning that stable funding for long-term atmospheric and oceanic measurements remains critical as these physical dynamics shift.[3]

Implications for global climate targets

Together, terrestrial and marine sinks have historically absorbed roughly half of all carbon dioxide released by fossil fuel combustion. This massive natural subsidy has significantly reduced the rate of warming and moderated the accumulation of atmospheric greenhouse gases.[2][4]

The revelation that the land sink has stagnated since 2009 forces a recalculation of future climate scenarios. If terrestrial ecosystems are already saturated, the remaining carbon budget for keeping global warming below critical thresholds is smaller than previously estimated.[3][4]

Climate models rely on accurate sink projections to determine the exact emissions reduction pathways required to meet international temperature targets. A fragile land sink combined with a warming, stratifying ocean leaves humanity with a narrower margin for error.[4][5]

Climate models rely on accurate sink projections to determine the exact emissions reduction pathways required to meet international temperature targets.

The 30-year dataset demonstrates that the Earth's natural systems cannot endlessly scale to accommodate rising industrial output. The burden of preventing severe climate disruption now shifts more heavily away from natural carbon sinks and toward immediate reductions in fossil fuel combustion.[2][3]

Key points

  1. The global ocean absorbed an average of 2.8 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide annually between 1990 and 2019, accounting for 35 percent of human fossil fuel emissions.
  2. Marine carbon absorption accelerated by 0.63 billion metric tons per decade, establishing the ocean as the dominant buffer against atmospheric accumulation.
  3. Terrestrial ecosystems failed to show sustained growth in carbon uptake over the same 30-year period, peaking around 2009 before generally declining.
  4. The stagnation of the land sink contradicts prevailing climate models, which predicted that rising carbon dioxide levels would continuously stimulate plant growth.

What we don’t know

  • Whether the terrestrial carbon sink will continue its post-2009 decline or stabilize at its current capacity.
  • The exact temperature threshold at which ocean thermal stratification will significantly throttle the transport of carbon into the deep abyssal waters.
  • How rapidly the loss of marine buffering capacity due to ocean acidification will accelerate the accumulation of atmospheric carbon dioxide.

How we got here

  1. 1958

    Charles David Keeling begins the continuous record of atmospheric carbon dioxide at Mauna Loa.

  2. 1989

    The Scripps O2 Program is founded to measure changes in atmospheric oxygen across a global network of remote sites.

  3. 1990 to 2019

    The global ocean absorbs an average of 2.8 billion metric tons of carbon dioxide annually, accelerating each decade.

  4. 2009

    The terrestrial carbon sink reaches its peak capacity before entering a period of general decline.

  5. Nov 2026

    Researchers publish a 30-year dataset confirming the divergence between the strengthening ocean sink and the stagnant land sink.

Marine Biogeochemists 40%Terrestrial Ecologists 35%Climate Modelers 25%
Marine Biogeochemists
Emphasize that while the ocean is currently mitigating climate change, the resulting acidification and thermal stratification threaten its future capacity.
Terrestrial Ecologists
Argue that the stagnation of the land sink exposes critical flaws in current models that overestimate the fertilizing effect of carbon dioxide on plants.
Climate Modelers
Focus on the urgent need to revise global carbon budgets and accelerate emission cuts to compensate for the stalling natural buffers.

Perspectives this story doesn't cover

  • Policymakers relying on land-based carbon offsets
  • Forestry management organizations

Sources

Source coverage

6 outlets

3 viewpoints surfaced

Marine Biogeochemists 40%Terrestrial Ecologists 35%Climate Modelers 25%
  1. [1]ScienceClimate Modelers

    Atmospheric O2 reveals a strengthening ocean carbon sink and a stagnant net land sink since 1990

    Read on Science →
  2. [2]UC San Diego TodayMarine Biogeochemists

    New Study Shows Ocean Taking Up Growing Share of Carbon Emissions While Land Absorption Has Stalled

    Read on UC San Diego Today →
  3. [3]University of ExeterTerrestrial Ecologists

    Ocean carbon sink strengthens while land carbon sink stalls new study finds

    Read on University of Exeter →
  4. [4]EurekAlert!Climate Modelers

    New study shows ocean taking up growing share of carbon emissions while land absorption has stalled

    Read on EurekAlert! →
  5. [5]Max-Planck-Institut für BiogeochemieTerrestrial Ecologists

    Kohlenstoff-Senke der Ozeane wird stärker, die Landsenke stagniert

    Read on Max-Planck-Institut für Biogeochemie →
  6. [6]Scientific FrontlineMarine Biogeochemists

    Ocean Carbon Sink Grows as Land Sink Stalls

    Read on Scientific Frontline →
Listen

Comments

Stay informed

Every angle. Every day.

Get Science stories with full source coverage and perspective breakdowns, free every day.