D.C. Circuit Upholds EPA PFAS Rule, Triggering Strict Superfund Cleanup Liability
A federal appeals court has unanimously upheld the EPA's designation of two 'forever chemicals' as Superfund hazardous substances, exposing a broad swath of downstream industries to strict cleanup liability.
By Sergei Orlov
Share this story
On August 18, 2026, a three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit handed down a unanimous decision that fundamentally alters the financial calculus of environmental cleanup in the United States. The court denied a consolidated industry challenge to the Environmental Protection Agency’s 2024 rule designating two of the most heavily studied per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances (PFAS)—PFOA and PFOS—as "hazardous substances" under the Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA).[1][4]
Better known as the Superfund law, CERCLA is the federal government's most powerful tool for forcing private parties to clean up contaminated sites. By upholding the EPA's designation, the D.C. Circuit has officially unlocked CERCLA's enforcement mechanisms for these two notorious "forever chemicals." The immediate legal consequence is that PFOA and PFOS are no longer merely "pollutants or contaminants," a category where the government typically bears the cleanup costs from public funds. They are now hazardous substances, meaning the EPA can compel responsible parties to perform cleanups and recover costs.[4][5]
To understand the magnitude of this shift, one must look at the mechanics of CERCLA liability. The statute imposes strict, joint, and several liability, which is also applied retroactively. Strict liability means a company can be held responsible regardless of whether it acted negligently or followed all environmental laws at the time of disposal. Joint and several liability means a single potentially responsible party can be forced to foot the bill for an entire site's cleanup, even if it only contributed a fraction of the waste.[4][6]
This legal architecture is designed to ensure that the polluter—not the taxpayer—pays for environmental remediation. However, the ubiquitous nature of PFAS complicates this framework immensely. Because PFOA and PFOS have been used for eight decades in everything from nonstick cookware to firefighting foam and stain-resistant fabrics, they are present in nearly every waste stream in the country.[3][4]
This ubiquity is why the ruling has sent shockwaves through "downstream" industries. The liability net does not just catch the chemical companies that manufactured PFAS; it extends to waste management companies, municipal landfills, water utilities, and construction firms that handled or received PFAS-containing materials. These entities, often referred to as "passive receivers," argued that the EPA's rule unfairly saddles them with catastrophic liability for chemicals they did not create and could not easily detect.[2][4]
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, the National Waste & Recycling Association, and other trade groups petitioned the D.C. Circuit to vacate the rule, raising three primary legal challenges. First, they argued that the EPA misinterpreted CERCLA's requirement that a substance "may present substantial danger" to public health. The industry groups contended this standard requires a finding that harm "will" occur upon release, demanding scientific certainty.[2][4]
The court, in an opinion authored by Judge Patricia Millett, flatly rejected this argument. The panel held that "may" carries its ordinary meaning of contingency or possibility, and that requiring absolute scientific certainty would "legislatively paralyze CERCLA." The court found that the EPA provided ample evidence of potential health impacts, including decreased infant birth weight, cardiovascular issues, and immunosuppression.[2][4]
Second, the petitioners claimed the EPA failed to provide adequate notice regarding its cost-benefit analysis and acted arbitrarily in its economic assessments. The court found that the EPA reasonably estimated cleanup costs and properly treated the shift of expenses from taxpayers to polluters as a statutory advantage aligned with CERCLA's design.[1][5]
Notably, the D.C. Circuit reached its conclusion without relying on Chevron deference—the longstanding doctrine overturned by the Supreme Court in 2024's Loper Bright decision. The panel interpreted the statute de novo and independently concluded that the text supported the EPA's authority to designate the chemicals based on the scientific record.[5]
While the ruling validates the EPA's regulatory authority, it leaves the practical reality of downstream liability highly unsettled. The EPA has issued an enforcement discretion policy stating it intends to focus on major manufacturers and industrial users, rather than passive receivers like landfills. However, an agency policy does not bind third parties.[2][6]
Under CERCLA, a major manufacturer targeted by the EPA can file contribution claims against other potentially responsible parties at the same site—including the waste management companies that hauled the material. The D.C. Circuit noted that CERCLA contains existing statutory protections, such as de minimis and innocent-landowner defenses, which may shield some downstream entities.[4][6]
Yet proving these defenses often requires years of expensive litigation. For passive receivers, the cost of defending against a contribution claim can be nearly as damaging as the cleanup liability itself. With the judicial route now closed, the battle over PFAS liability shifts from the courthouse to Capitol Hill, where waste and water industries are expected to intensify lobbying for a statutory exemption from CERCLA. Until such legislation passes, the Superfund net remains cast wide.[2][4]
Key points
- The D.C. Circuit unanimously upheld the EPA's designation of PFOA and PFOS as CERCLA hazardous substances.
- The ruling shifts cleanup costs from taxpayers to polluters under a strict, joint, and several liability framework.
- Downstream 'passive receivers' like landfills and water utilities face potential exposure to third-party contribution claims.
- The court rejected industry arguments that the EPA needed absolute scientific certainty of harm to regulate the chemicals.
Open questions
- How aggressively major chemical manufacturers will pursue third-party contribution claims against downstream passive receivers.
- Whether Congress will pass legislation granting a statutory exemption from CERCLA liability for water utilities and waste management companies.
- How the EPA will apply this legal precedent to designate additional PFAS compounds as hazardous substances in the future.
Timeline
April 2024
The EPA issues a final rule designating PFOA and PFOS as hazardous substances under CERCLA.
June 2024
Industry groups, including the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the National Waste & Recycling Association, file petitions to challenge the rule.
January 2026
The D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals hears oral arguments regarding the EPA's statutory authority and cost-benefit analysis.
August 18, 2026
The D.C. Circuit unanimously denies the industry petitions, upholding the EPA's hazardous substance designation.
- Environmental Regulators & Advocates
- Argue that the polluter-pays principle must be enforced to protect public health and relieve taxpayers of cleanup costs.
- Downstream Passive Receivers
- Argue that strict liability unfairly penalizes waste handlers and utilities that did not manufacture PFAS but merely received them in public waste streams.
- Corporate Legal Analysts
- Focus on the expansive nature of CERCLA liability and advise companies to prepare for third-party contribution claims and complex litigation.
Perspectives this story doesn't cover
- Local municipalities facing increased costs for water treatment and waste disposal.
- Communities living near historical PFAS contamination sites awaiting remediation.
Sources
[1]Holland & KnightCorporate Legal AnalystsD.C. Circuit Upholds EPA Designation of PFOA and PFOS as CERCLA Hazardous Substances
Read on Holland & Knight →
[2]Waste DiveDownstream Passive ReceiversD.C. Circuit Court of Appeals upholds EPA's PFAS hazardous substance designation
Read on Waste Dive →
[3]EarthjusticeEnvironmental Regulators & AdvocatesD.C. Circuit Upholds EPA Decision to List PFOA and PFOS as Hazardous Substances
Read on Earthjustice →
[4]ArentFox SchiffCorporate Legal AnalystsForever Chemicals, Forever Liability? DC Circuit Upholds EPA PFAS Designation
Read on ArentFox Schiff →
[5]Liskow & LewisCorporate Legal AnalystsD.C. Circuit Upholds EPA's Designation of PFOA and PFOS as CERCLA Hazardous Substances
Read on Liskow & Lewis →
[6]MondaqCorporate Legal AnalystsD.C. Circuit Upholds EPA's Designation Of PFOA And PFOS As CERCLA Hazardous Substances
Read on Mondaq →
More in Content Types
See all →Identity Architecture
OAuth 2.0 Authorization Code Flow Isolates Passwords from Third-Party Applications
6 sources
Llama 3.1
How Meta's Llama 3.1 405B Architecture Actually Works
4 sources
Causal AI
How Directed Acyclic Graphs Separate Causation from Correlation in Observational Data
4 sources
Cryptographic Privacy
Zero-Knowledge Proofs Verify Truth Without Data but Face Computational Bottlenecks
10 sources
Comments
Every angle. Every day.
Get Content Types stories with full source coverage and perspective breakdowns, free every day.




