Skip to main content
Prediction MarketsKalshi· 7 min read· in Finance

Kalshi Faces Monday Court Hearing Over New York Order Threatening National Operations

A New York state judge will hear arguments Monday on a proposed temporary restraining order against Kalshi. The prediction market warns that the state's phrasing could force it to shut down its $22 billion exchange nationwide.

By Simran Chawla

Share this story

Listen

Prediction market operator Kalshi faces a critical legal test on Monday morning in a Manhattan courtroom. New York Supreme Court Justice Melissa Crane will hear arguments on a proposed temporary restraining order that could halt the platform's operations. The hearing represents the culmination of a months-long jurisdictional battle between state and federal regulators.[1][3]

New York Attorney General Letitia James is seeking to bar Kalshi from offering contracts "within or from New York," arguing the platform operates an unlicensed gambling business. Because Kalshi is headquartered in New York, the company's lawyers warn that this specific phrasing would effectively shut down the exchange nationwide. The proposed order would also restrict trading by users under the age of 21.[1][2][4]

The financial stakes for the prediction market are massive, with Kalshi currently handling an estimated $178 billion in annualized trading volume. The company recently achieved a $22 billion valuation following a $1 billion funding round led by Coatue Management. A nationwide shutdown would likely force the immediate liquidation of all open positions across the platform.[1][4]

The Monday hearing follows a rapid sequence of federal court defeats for Kalshi and its federal regulator over the past week. On Thursday, November 19, U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick ruled that the federal court lacked subject-matter jurisdiction. He ordered the enforcement lawsuit to be sent back to the state court system immediately.[4]

The Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) attempted to intervene on Kalshi's behalf, filing an emergency motion to block New York's enforcement action. However, U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield denied that request from the bench late Friday following a telephone hearing. Schofield concluded that the federal regulator had "not established a likelihood of success on the merits" of its core argument.[1][3][5]

The Federal Versus State Turf War

The core legal dispute centers on whether Kalshi's event contracts constitute gambling or federally regulated derivatives. The CFTC maintains that federal derivatives law preempts state gambling statutes, positioning the agency as Kalshi's sole sector regulator. The commission has argued that any state-level shutdown of the exchange poses an "existential threat" to the business.[3]

The New York Attorney General is seeking up to $36 billion in penalties, a figure that exceeds Kalshi's entire corporate valuation.

Kalshi has operated as a CFTC-designated contract market since 2020, offering users the ability to trade on the outcomes of sports, cultural events, and elections. The federal regulator has backed the company with unusual force, issuing its own emergency order on August 11, 2026. That federal directive explicitly ordered Kalshi to keep its exchange running to prevent a major market disturbance.[3][4]

If Justice Crane grants the state's temporary restraining order on Monday, Kalshi will be caught between conflicting mandates. A state court would be ordering the platform to halt operations, while a federal order demands it remain open. No court has yet determined how to resolve a direct collision between these two specific directives.[4]

New York's aggressive posture is not an isolated incident, as the CFTC has recently sued twelve different states that sought to restrict Kalshi's activities. Utah authorities even brought criminal charges against the company and its co-founders, Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara. The outcome in New York could set a definitive precedent for how prediction markets are policed nationwide.[3]

Kalshi spokesperson Elisabeth Diana defended the company's compliance record in a statement on Friday. She emphasized that the platform has consistently followed the law and has operated under federal oversight since the Biden administration. The company maintains that its federal registration should shield it from state-level gambling enforcement.[3]

The Attorney General's Case

Attorney General James originally filed the enforcement action on July 31, 2026, describing Kalshi as an "illegal gambling operation." The state's complaint focuses heavily on consumer protection and age restrictions. James argues that Kalshi allows users as young as 18 to trade, directly violating New York's minimum age of 21 for mobile sports betting.[3][4]

The lawsuit also targets Kalshi's listing of contracts tied to New York college sports teams, which state regulators strictly prohibit. James contends that federal registration does not excuse any company from complying with state licensing, taxation, and consumer protection rules. The state is seeking to permanently bar the platform from advertising on college campuses.[1][4]

The financial penalties sought by New York are severe, with the state demanding restitution and the forfeiture of profits. One court filing indicated that the attorney general is seeking up to $36 billion in total damages. That figure significantly exceeds Kalshi's entire corporate valuation, creating a massive liability even if the exchange avoids an immediate shutdown.[4]

The jurisdictional battle centers on whether federal derivatives law preempts state gambling statutes.

The New York State Gaming Commission had previously issued a cease-and-desist notice to Kalshi in October 2025. The state agreed to defer enforcement while the company pursued preliminary injunctive relief in federal court. After Kalshi's requests for federal injunctions were denied in July 2026, James proceeded with the massive civil lawsuit.[4]

Kalshi's legal team at Milbank submitted a late-night letter to Justice Crane on Thursday, requesting an immediate status conference. The lawyers asked for formal notice and an opportunity to file arguments before any renewed temporary restraining order is granted. They argued that James has failed to establish the kind of emergency that justifies an immediate, ex parte shutdown.[1][4]

Market Ripple Effects

The threat of a nationwide shutdown has already begun to impact the broader financial ecosystem connected to Kalshi. Retail brokerage Robinhood, which recently began offering sports event contracts through Kalshi's infrastructure, faces significant disruption to its new product line. Robinhood shares closed down 9.44% on Friday, though analysts noted the drop coincided with a broader market selloff.[4]

If Kalshi is forced to halt operations, competitors are poised to absorb its massive trading volume. Robinhood executives have indicated that order flow could be redirected to alternative platforms like Rothera and Crypto.com by early next year. The uncertainty has left institutional investors and market makers evaluating their exposure to the prediction market sector.[4]

The regulatory clash highlights the growing mainstream adoption of event contracts, which allow users to hedge risks or speculate on real-world outcomes. Proponents argue these markets provide valuable predictive data and operate more transparently than traditional sportsbooks. Critics, including several state attorneys general, view them as thinly veiled gambling platforms that bypass local consumer protections.[3][4]

The CFTC's robust defense of Kalshi marks a significant shift in how federal regulators approach novel financial products. By actively suing states to protect a designated contract market, the commission is asserting broad authority over the emerging asset class. The federal agency maintains that fragmented state regulations would destroy the utility of national derivatives markets.[3]

Despite the federal backing, the string of recent procedural losses has left Kalshi vulnerable to state-level enforcement. Judge Broderick's decision to remand the case was based strictly on venue, leaving the core question of whether Kalshi violates New York gambling law entirely unresolved. That substantive debate will now unfold in the state court system.[4]

The CFTC has actively sued multiple states to protect Kalshi's operations, arguing that state-level shutdowns pose an existential threat to national derivatives markets.

The Path Forward

Monday's hearing at 11:30 a.m. ET will determine the immediate fate of the $22 billion exchange. If Justice Crane grants the temporary restraining order with the "conducted from New York" language, Kalshi will likely be forced to suspend all trading. The company would then face the complex task of unwinding billions of dollars in open positions.[1][2][4]

Even if Kalshi successfully fends off the temporary restraining order, the underlying $36 billion lawsuit remains a formidable threat. The company faces the prospect of years of costly litigation in state court, defending its business model against a well-resourced attorney general. The sheer size of the potential penalty casts a long shadow over the platform's future growth.[4]

The case could ultimately reach the U.S. Supreme Court, given the stark conflict between federal derivatives law and state gambling statutes. Legal experts note that the recent rulings against the CFTC increase the likelihood of a high-court intervention to resolve the jurisdictional dispute. Until then, prediction markets operate in a precarious legal gray area.[3][5]

Supreme Court, given the stark conflict between federal derivatives law and state gambling statutes.

For the 1.2 million New Yorkers and countless national users who trade on Kalshi, the platform's availability hangs in the balance. The company has expressed a desire to work with state officials on a resolution that protects consumers while preserving the market. However, the aggressive legal maneuvers from both sides suggest a settlement is not imminent.[3][4]

As the Monday hearing approaches, the broader financial industry is watching closely. The outcome will not only dictate Kalshi's survival but also signal whether state regulators can effectively veto federally approved financial innovations. The decision will shape the boundary between federal market oversight and state consumer protection for years to come.[3][4]

Key points

  1. New York Supreme Court Justice Melissa Crane will hear arguments Monday on a temporary restraining order against Kalshi.
  2. Kalshi warns that the proposed order barring operations 'conducted from New York' would force a nationwide shutdown of its $22 billion exchange.
  3. Federal judges recently denied the CFTC's emergency requests to block the state's enforcement action, leaving the decision to the state court.
  4. New York Attorney General Letitia James is seeking up to $36 billion in penalties, alleging the platform violates state gambling and age laws.

What we don’t know

  • How Justice Melissa Crane will rule on the temporary restraining order during Monday's hearing.
  • Whether Kalshi would actually be forced to liquidate all open positions nationwide if the order is granted.
  • If the U.S. Supreme Court will eventually intervene to resolve the conflict between federal derivatives law and state gambling statutes.

How we got here

  1. July 2026

    New York Attorney General Letitia James files an enforcement action against Kalshi for alleged unlicensed gambling.

  2. August 2026

    The CFTC issues an emergency order directing Kalshi to keep its exchange running under federal requirements.

  3. Nov 19, 2026

    U.S. District Judge Vernon Broderick remands the New York enforcement lawsuit back to state court.

  4. Nov 20, 2026

    U.S. District Judge Lorna Schofield denies the CFTC's second emergency request to block the state action.

  5. Nov 23, 2026

    New York Supreme Court Justice Melissa Crane is scheduled to hear arguments on the temporary restraining order.

Federal Regulators 40%State Prosecutors 40%Prediction Market Operators 20%
Federal Regulators
Argue that national derivatives law preempts state gambling statutes.
State Prosecutors
Contend that federal registration does not exempt platforms from state consumer protection laws.
Prediction Market Operators
Warn that fragmented state enforcement threatens the viability of national exchanges.

Perspectives this story doesn't cover

  • Retail traders holding open positions on Kalshi
  • Institutional market makers providing liquidity to the exchange

Sources

Source coverage

5 outlets

3 viewpoints surfaced

Federal Regulators 40%State Prosecutors 40%Prediction Market Operators 20%
  1. [1]The BlockState Prosecutors

    Kalshi faces Monday hearing on New York order it says would shut down its exchange nationwide

    Read on The Block →
  2. [2]The DefiantPrediction Market Operators

    Kalshi Says Proposed New York Order Could Shut Exchange

    Read on The Defiant →
  3. [3]GizmodoFederal Regulators

    Kalshi Claims New York's Lawsuit Could Shut It Down Everywhere

    Read on Gizmodo →
  4. [4]24/7 Wall St.State Prosecutors

    Kalshi Says New York Could Shut It Down Nationwide

    Read on 24/7 Wall St. →
  5. [5]Investing.comFederal Regulators

    US judge rejects CFTC emergency bid to block New York from policing Kalshi

    Read on Investing.com →
Listen

Comments

Stay informed

Every angle. Every day.

Get Finance stories with full source coverage and perspective breakdowns, free every day.