Skip to main content
Data PrivacyPolicy Decision· 2 min read· in Shopping & Reviews

California Governor Vetoes Bill Banning Sale of Sensitive Consumer Data

Governor Gavin Newsom rejected a proposed ban on trading sensitive consumer information, leaving the burden on individuals to actively opt out of data sharing.

By Amelie Rousseau

How this story has developed

This report is part of a developing story — read the earlier chapters below.

  1. California Legislature Passes Bill to Ban the Sale of Sensitive Personal Data
  2. California Governor Vetoes Bill Banning Sale of Sensitive Consumer Data (this article)
Advertising Industry 50%Consumer Privacy Advocates 50%
Advertising Industry
Argues that banning the sale of sensitive data harms small businesses and disrupts the targeted marketing ecosystem.
Consumer Privacy Advocates
Argues that sensitive data like health and location should be protected by default, rather than requiring consumers to navigate complex opt-out processes.

Perspectives this story doesn't cover

  • Small business owners relying on targeted ads
  • Independent data brokers

Why this matters

Without a default ban, consumers must continue to manually navigate opt-out settings for location, health, and financial data across individual apps and data brokers. However, newly signed companion legislation now allows residents to force data brokers to delete purchased information.

California Governor Gavin Newsom vetoed a legislative ban on the sale of sensitive consumer data on September 27, 2026, maintaining the advertising industry's ability to trade location, health, and financial information until lawmakers introduce a revised framework in the 2027 legislative session.[4][5]

The rejected legislation would have shifted the state's privacy model from an opt-out system to a strict opt-in requirement for 3 specific sensitive categories. By vetoing the measure, the governor aligned with advertising and business groups who argued the restrictions would severely disrupt digital marketing and the operational revenue of small businesses relying on targeted ads in a $200 billion US digital ad market.[2][3]

Privacy Daily reported that the decision "Pleases Advertisers," as it preserves the data ecosystem necessary for personalized shopping experiences and precise ad targeting.[3]

Consumer advocacy groups expressed immediate disappointment, noting that the veto leaves individuals responsible for manually navigating complex privacy settings across more than 500 registered data brokers in the state. Consumer Reports highlighted the setback, emphasizing the ongoing burden on residents to protect their personal metrics.[1]

Illustration: Without a default ban, consumers must continue to manually opt out of data sharing.
Consumer Reports highlighted the setback, emphasizing the ongoing burden on residents to protect their personal metrics.

Despite the veto on the sales ban, the governor did advance a separate piece of the privacy package. On September 28, 2026, Newsom signed Senate Bill 923 (SB 923), which expands the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), a landmark law originally passed in 2018.[5][6]

Privisy confirmed that with the signing of SB 923, "CCPA Deletion Now Covers Bought Data." This means California residents can now demand that data brokers delete personal information even if that data was purchased from a third party, closing a loophole that previously exempted bought data from deletion requests.[6]

For consumers managing their digital footprint, the immediate actionable takeaway is to utilize existing CCPA opt-out mechanisms and the newly granted deletion rights. Because default protections for sensitive data remain absent from state law, users must actively submit deletion requests to registered data brokers, who then have 45 days to respond under standard CCPA rules.[1][6]

The legislative debate is expected to resume next year, with privacy advocates preparing to introduce modified proposals that address the governor's stated concerns while attempting to secure tighter default restrictions on the state's data brokerage industry.[4][5]

Viewpoints in depth

Advertising Industry

Preserving the targeted marketing ecosystem.

Advertising and business groups argue that a strict ban on selling sensitive data would cripple the digital marketing ecosystem that supports free online services. They maintain that small businesses rely heavily on targeted advertising to reach local customers efficiently, and that shifting to a strict opt-in model would drastically reduce the availability of actionable consumer insights.

Consumer Privacy Advocates

Pushing for default protections over manual opt-outs.

Privacy advocates argue that sensitive information—such as precise geolocation, personal health conditions, and financial metrics—should be protected by default. They contend that the current opt-out system places an unreasonable burden on consumers, who must navigate complex settings across hundreds of individual data brokers to secure their personal information.

Key points

  • Governor Gavin Newsom vetoed a bill that would have banned the sale of sensitive consumer data.
  • The advertising industry opposed the ban, arguing it would harm small businesses and digital marketing.
  • Newsom signed SB 923, expanding the CCPA to allow consumers to demand deletion of purchased data.
  • Consumers must continue to manually opt out of data sharing for location, health, and financial information.

Sources

Source coverage

6 outlets

2 viewpoints surfaced

Advertising Industry 50%Consumer Privacy Advocates 50%
  1. [1]Consumer ReportsConsumer Privacy Advocates

    California governor vetoes bill banning the sale of sensitive consumer data

    Read on Consumer Reports →
  2. [2]MediaPostAdvertising Industry

    Newsom Vetoes Ban On Sharing Sensitive Data

    Read on MediaPost →
  3. [3]Privacy DailyAdvertising Industry

    Veto of Proposed Calif. Ban on Selling Sensitive Data Pleases Advertisers

    Read on Privacy Daily →
  4. [4]VitalLaw.com

    Governor Vetoes California Bill on Sensitive Data-Sharing

    Read on VitalLaw.com →
  5. [5]CA Governor's Office

    Governor Newsom issues legislative update 9.27.2026

    Read on CA Governor's Office →
  6. [6]PrivisyConsumer Privacy Advocates

    SB 923 Signed: CCPA Deletion Now Covers Bought Data

    Read on Privisy →

Comments

Stay informed

Every angle. Every day.

Get Shopping & Reviews stories with full source coverage and perspective breakdowns delivered to your inbox.