Skip to main content
Heritage RepatriationTrade-off AnalysisAug 27, 2026, 7:00 AM· 4 min read· in culture

Indigenous Advocates Race to Raise $20M to Prevent Private Sale of Sacred Artifacts From Closed Swiss Museum

A Manitoba-led delegation is urgently raising $20 million to purchase thousands of sacred Indigenous artifacts from a retiring Swiss collector. The grassroots effort aims to prevent the massive collection from being dispersed into the global private antiquities market.

By Claire Lefevre

Indigenous Repatriation Advocates 60%Institutional Observers 20%Private Antiquities Collectors 20%
Indigenous Repatriation Advocates
Argue that sacred artifacts hold spiritual power and must be returned to descendant communities rather than sold for profit.
Institutional Observers
Focus on the legal complexities of private ownership and the logistical challenges of mass repatriation.
Private Antiquities Collectors
View historical artifacts as legally acquired personal property and valuable financial assets.

At a glance

  • The Indian Land Museum in Gossau, Switzerland, closed in late 2025, leaving thousands of Indigenous artifacts in storage.
  • The retiring Swiss collector is seeking up to $17 million for the massive collection.
  • A Manitoba-led delegation is trying to raise $20 million to buy the items and return them to North America.
  • Because the collection is privately owned, international repatriation laws do not apply.
  • Advocates fear the items will be auctioned off to private buyers if the funds are not raised.
$20 million
Total fundraising goal
$13M–$17M
Estimated purchase price
3,500+
Estimated artifacts in collection
$95,000
Market value of a single 19th-century cradleboard

Why it matters now

The fate of this collection highlights a massive loophole in global repatriation efforts: while state museums are increasingly returning stolen heritage, private collections remain largely unregulated. The success or failure of this $20 million campaign could set a precedent for how descendant communities reclaim their history directly from the open market.

For three decades, a massive collection of North American history sat quietly above a Migros supermarket in Gossau, Switzerland. Inside the privately owned Indian Land Museum, thousands of sacred Indigenous artifacts—from 19th-century Cheyenne cradleboards to original Winchester rifles used at the Battle of the Little Bighorn—were displayed in glass cases, a continent away from the communities that created them.[1]

The tension at the heart of the story is one of ownership versus heritage. At the end of 2025, 67-year-old Swiss collector Vincent Escriba closed the museum's doors, citing waning public interest. Now, the collection of up to 10,000 items sits packed in storage boxes, waiting to be sold to fund his retirement. The legal reality is stark: because the artifacts are private property, they fall entirely outside the jurisdiction of international repatriation treaties.[1][2]

Across the Atlantic, a Manitoba-led delegation of Indigenous advocates is racing against the clock to resolve that tension. The "Bringing Them Home" project has launched an urgent campaign to raise $20 million to purchase the entire collection en masse, effectively buying back their own heritage from the open market.[1][3]

"They are all sitting in boxes in Switzerland right now, so there's a real urgency about this," said Coleen Rajotte, a Cree advocate and member of the project. The group fears that without immediate funding, the items will be auctioned off individually to private buyers in Dubai or New York, disappearing into billionaires' offices as decorative showpieces.[4]

The $20 million campaign includes the purchase price and logistical costs.

The collection is vast and historically profound. It includes intricately beaded bandolier bags from Algonquin, Ojibway, and Cree communities, elk-foot bags dating back to 1780, and sacred pipes and feathered headdresses. Escriba, who began collecting in the late 1970s, spent decades traveling to North America to amass the items, carefully preserving them in his Swiss facility.[1][2][3]

Escriba, who began collecting in the late 1970s, spent decades traveling to North America to amass the items, carefully preserving them in his Swiss facility.

For the Indigenous delegates who traveled to Switzerland to inspect the collection before the museum closed, the items are far more than historical curiosities. "When I was there in Switzerland, I felt the energy of our ancestors," said Karl Stone, a councillor for the Dakota Tipi First Nation.[1]

"They're not just things you display like trophies," Stone added. "They are sacred and they are holy to our people, and they need to be looked after with prayer." The delegation believes the artifacts hold spiritual power that must be reconnected with descendant communities to facilitate cultural healing and restore identity to younger generations.[1][2][4]

The financial hurdle, however, is immense. Escriba is currently asking between $13 million and $17 million for the collection. The Bringing Them Home project is seeking an additional $3 million to cover the costs of transportation, secure climate-controlled storage, and professional authentication.[1][3]

The Bringing Them Home project is racing to secure funding before the collection is sold to private buyers.

Gerald Neufeld, a retired engineer and Ojibway speaker who accompanied the delegation, noted the high market value of individual pieces. A single 19th-century Cheyenne baby cradle, similar to ones in the Swiss collection, recently sold for $95,000 through an antiquities clearinghouse. The math of the open market is unforgiving to grassroots repatriation efforts.[1][4]

Despite the ticking clock, there is a window of cooperation. Escriba has expressed a willingness to work with the Indigenous advocates, assuring them he has not yet begun selling the items piece by piece. He has given the group time to assemble the necessary capital, though his retirement timeline looms over the negotiations.[2]

The campaign is now urging federal, First Nations, and tribal governments in both Canada and the United States to intervene and provide financial backing. While national museums and universities have increasingly reckoned with their roles in holding sacred items, private collections remain a massive, unregulated blind spot in global repatriation efforts.[3]

Individual artifacts can fetch massive premiums on the open antiquities market.

If the $20 million can be raised, the group plans to return specific items to their respective nations across the Prairies and the US. For the rest, they are discussing the possibility of establishing a new Indigenous-led museum in Winnipeg—ensuring that the artifacts are finally displayed on their own terms, on their own land.[1][2][4]

Different angles

Path 1: Indigenous Trust Purchase & Repatriation

Acquiring the collection en masse through the $20M Bringing Them Home campaign.

For: Ensures the collection remains intact and returns to Turtle Island. Allows for culturally appropriate care, ceremonial reintegration, and the return of spiritual heritage to descendant communities. Against: Requires an immense, immediate capital injection ($20M) that grassroots organizations struggle to raise without state backing. Evidence: The group estimates $13M–$17M for the purchase and $3M for logistics, requiring unprecedented coordination among governments, museums, and private donors. Fits well when: Broad coalitions of government and private donors mobilize quickly to fund the buyout. Does not fit when: Fundraising stalls, forcing the seller to seek other buyers to fund his retirement.

Path 2: Private Auction and Market Dispersal

Selling the artifacts individually or in lots on the open antiquities market.

For: Maximizes financial return for the retiring collector. Individual pieces can fetch high market premiums, satisfying global demand for rare historical antiquities. Against: Permanently severs the cultural and spiritual connection between the artifacts and their descendant communities. Items disappear into private, inaccessible collections worldwide. Evidence: Advocates warn of items ending up 'under glass in a billionaire's office in Dubai or New York,' noting that single cradleboards can sell for $95,000. Fits well when: The seller prioritizes immediate liquidation and maximum profit over ethical considerations. Does not fit when: Cultural heritage preservation and the spiritual rights of descendant communities are prioritized over pure market economics.

Path 3: State or Institutional Intervention

A government or major national museum stepping in to purchase or legally compel the transfer.

For: Bypasses the grassroots fundraising hurdle by utilizing state budgets. Provides immediate climate-controlled storage, professional conservation, and legal protection. Against: Shifts ownership from a private European collector to a North American institution, rather than directly to the Indigenous nations, potentially sparking secondary repatriation battles. Private property laws in Switzerland also heavily restrict state seizure. Evidence: Advocates note that if this were a state-owned Swiss museum, international repatriation laws would apply, but private ownership negates those treaties. Fits well when: Governments are willing to act as temporary custodians and fund the buyout on behalf of Indigenous groups. Does not fit when: Bureaucratic delays outlast the seller's patience, or institutions refuse to relinquish ultimate ownership.

Sources

Source coverage

4 outlets

3 viewpoints surfaced

Indigenous Repatriation Advocates 60%Institutional Observers 20%Private Antiquities Collectors 20%
  1. [1]CBC NewsIndigenous Repatriation Advocates

    Manitoba Indigenous advocates seek $20M to repatriate thousands of items from Swiss collection

    Read on CBC News
  2. [2]Town & Country TodayIndigenous Repatriation Advocates

    'Whatever it takes:' Indigenous group seeks help repatriating items from Switzerland

    Read on Town & Country Today
  3. [3]Airdrie City ViewInstitutional Observers

    'Whatever it takes:' Indigenous group seeks help repatriating items from Switzerland

    Read on Airdrie City View
  4. [4]Western WheelPrivate Antiquities Collectors

    'Whatever it takes:' Indigenous group seeks help repatriating items from Switzerland

    Read on Western Wheel

Comments

Stay informed

Every angle. Every day.

Get culture stories with full source coverage and perspective breakdowns delivered to your inbox.