ASEAN and China Agree to 80 Percent of South China Sea Code but Miss Year-End Deadline
Negotiators have secured a provisional consensus on the majority of the maritime framework, but deeply contested disputes over legal enforcement and geographic boundaries will delay the final treaty into 2027.
By Anaya Sharma
Share this story
Diplomats at the 49th ASEAN Summit in Manila have locked in roughly 80 percent of the text for a long-negotiated maritime framework governing the South China Sea. Despite the progress, regional officials confirmed that the 10-member bloc and Beijing will fail to finalize the treaty before their self-imposed 2026 deadline expires.[1][2]
Philippine Foreign Affairs Secretary Theresa Lazaro announced the progress to regional diplomats, characterizing the current draft as a substantial completion of the framework. However, she acknowledged that the remaining unresolved sections contain the most deeply contested geopolitical issues between Beijing and the bloc.[2][6]
"No binding Code of Conduct on the South China Sea will be finalized under the ASEAN chairship of the Philippines," Lazaro stated during the summit proceedings. The admission formally pushes the conclusion of the treaty into 2027, despite prior commitments to wrap up negotiations this year.[1][6]
The Association of Southeast Asian Nations has spent years attempting to establish rules of engagement for the strategic waterway. An estimated $3 trillion in global maritime trade passes through the corridor annually, making the regulatory framework a critical priority for international shipping and regional security.[3][4]
While the provisional text establishes communication protocols and environmental cooperation guidelines, the final 20 percent of the document remains heavily disputed. Negotiators have yet to agree on whether the final code will carry the force of international law or function merely as a diplomatic guideline.[3]
The remaining sticking points
The Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs noted that significant sticking points continue to stall the final rounds of drafting. Foremost among these is the geographic scope of the agreement, as member states disagree on exactly which contested waters and island chains the code should cover.[3]
China claims nearly the entire South China Sea under its expansive maritime boundaries, a position that overlaps with the exclusive economic zones of the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, and Brunei. Beijing has historically resisted defining specific coordinates for the code's jurisdiction to avoid legitimizing rival territorial claims.[1]
Enforcement mechanisms represent another major hurdle for the drafting committee. Several ASEAN members, led by the Philippines and Vietnam, demand a legally binding treaty with clear, enforceable penalties for state vessels that violate the agreed rules of engagement.[3][6]
Chinese negotiators have consistently pushed for a non-binding political consensus, similar to the 2002 Declaration on the Conduct of Parties. That earlier framework failed to prevent the subsequent militarization of artificial islands and the escalation of coast guard skirmishes across the disputed reefs.[1][7]
The delay past the 2026 deadline reflects the difficulty of bridging this fundamental gap in legal interpretation. Regional diplomats indicated that rushing a compromised text would undermine the primary purpose of the negotiations, leaving smaller coastal states vulnerable to maritime coercion.[1]
A missed year-end deadline
Leaders at the 49th ASEAN Summit had initially hoped to use the Manila gathering as a signing ceremony for the completed code. Instead, the bloc is preparing to issue a joint statement acknowledging the 80 percent completion mark while outlining a revised timeline for the remaining chapters.[4][5]
The missed deadline extends a diplomatic process that has already consumed more than two decades of regional summits. Formal consultations for the current binding code began in 2013, following repeated failures to manage maritime incidents through voluntary bilateral agreements.[4][7]
Progress accelerated briefly in 2023 when negotiators agreed on a single draft negotiating text, aiming for a three-year timeline to reach a final resolution. The failure to meet that 2026 target underscores the entrenched positions of the claimant states regarding their sovereign rights.[1][7]
Philippine officials, hosting the summit, faced domestic pressure to secure a robust agreement following a year of intense maritime confrontations. Philippine and Chinese coast guard vessels have repeatedly collided near the Second Thomas Shoal and Sabina Shoal throughout 2026.[2]
These physical clashes have heightened the urgency for a functional crisis management mechanism. Without a formalized code, naval commanders and coast guard captains operate without standardized rules for de-escalation, increasing the risk of a localized dispute triggering a broader military conflict.[3]
Strategic implications for the region
The prolonged negotiations also reflect broader geopolitical competition between Washington and Beijing. The United States, while not a party to the territorial disputes, conducts regular freedom of navigation operations through the South China Sea to challenge expansive maritime claims.[1][3]
Chinese diplomats have previously attempted to insert clauses into the code that would restrict ASEAN states from conducting joint military exercises with outside powers. This provision faces strong opposition from Manila, which recently expanded its defense cooperation arrangements with the United States and Australia.[3]
The 80 percent provisional agreement does secure some tactical wins for regional stability, including standardized radio communication formats and search-and-rescue coordination protocols. These technical agreements aim to prevent miscalculations between commercial fishing fleets and state maritime militias.[2]
However, maritime security analysts warn that technical protocols cannot substitute for a binding resolution on state behavior. Until the rules governing blockades, water cannon usage, and vessel ramming are codified, the physical risks to mariners in the contested zones remain severe.[3][6]
The transition of the ASEAN chairship next year will shift the diplomatic burden to a new host nation. The incoming chair will inherit the complex task of mediating the final 20 percent of the text, requiring consensus from all 10 member states and Beijing.[4][6]
The diplomatic path forward
Foreign Affairs Secretary Lazaro emphasized that the Philippines will continue to push for a substantive and effective code during the remainder of its term. The Department of Foreign Affairs has prioritized legal clarity over diplomatic speed in the final drafting sessions.[6]
ASEAN leaders are expected to formally endorse the progress report before the 49th Summit concludes. The joint statement will likely mandate the joint working group to resume intensive negotiations in early 2027, focusing exclusively on the disputed legal and geographic provisions.[4][5]
The current draft relies heavily on the principles established by the 1982 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. Ensuring that the final code remains entirely consistent with UNCLOS has been a non-negotiable demand for the majority of the Southeast Asian bloc.[3]
China's willingness to finalize the remaining text will serve as a critical indicator of its broader regional strategy. Beijing has consistently stated its desire to manage maritime disputes internally, without the involvement of international tribunals or Western military alliances.[1][7]
For now, the provisional agreement locks in the technical progress achieved over the past three years. Negotiators have successfully insulated the agreed 80 percent of the text from being reopened, narrowing the battlefield for the upcoming diplomatic rounds.[2]
The focus now shifts to the working-level committees tasked with bridging the final legal divides. Their success or failure in 2027 will determine whether the South China Sea operates under a shared rule of law or remains governed by the balance of maritime force.[1][5]
Regional economies are watching the diplomatic process closely, as the persistent maritime tensions have begun to impact offshore energy exploration. Several ASEAN states have delayed natural gas projects in their exclusive economic zones due to the lack of a clear security framework.[3]
Key points
- Philippine officials confirmed that 80 percent of the South China Sea Code of Conduct is now provisionally agreed upon.
- Negotiators will miss their 2026 deadline to finalize the pact due to unresolved disputes over enforcement and geographic scope.
- The Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs stated that no binding code will be concluded during its current ASEAN chairship.
- The remaining 20 percent of the text contains the most contentious issues, including whether the final framework will carry the force of international law.
What we don’t know
- Whether the incoming ASEAN chair will have the diplomatic leverage to force a compromise on the remaining 20 percent of the text.
- Exactly which geographic coordinates and disputed island chains will be covered by the final jurisdiction of the code.
- How the framework will address the presence of foreign military vessels conducting freedom of navigation operations in the region.
How we got here
2002
ASEAN and China sign the non-binding Declaration on the Conduct of Parties in the South China Sea.
2013
Formal consultations begin on drafting a legally binding Code of Conduct to replace the earlier declaration.
2023
Negotiators agree on a single draft negotiating text and establish a three-year timeline for completion.
Nov 2026
Officials confirm the 2026 deadline will be missed, with 80 percent of the provisional text completed.
- ASEAN Host Nation View
- Emphasizes the need for a legally binding framework anchored in UNCLOS to protect the exclusive economic zones of smaller coastal states.
- Regional and International Observers
- Focuses on the broader geopolitical delays and the difficulty of reaching a consensus-based political arrangement with Beijing.
Perspectives this story doesn't cover
- Commercial shipping operators navigating the contested corridors
- Offshore energy consortiums awaiting legal clarity for exploration
Sources
[1]Associated PressRegional and International ObserversRegional diplomats say China and Southeast Asian countries have made progress on a South China Sea pact but won't be able to conclude negotiations this year as agreed
Read on Associated Press →
[2]The Philippine StarASEAN Host Nation ViewASEAN, China reach substantial completion of South China Sea code, bloc chair Philippines says
Read on The Philippine Star →
[3]INQUIRER.netASEAN Host Nation ViewDFA: South China Sea code 80% complete, but 'sticking points' remain
Read on INQUIRER.net →
[4]Manila BulletinASEAN Host Nation ViewSouth China Sea Code of Conduct: Will ASEAN finalize agreement at 49th Summit?
Read on Manila Bulletin →
[5]VERA FilesASEAN Host Nation ViewASEAN leaders to issue statement on South China Sea Code of Conduct
Read on VERA Files →
[6]ABS-CBN NewsASEAN Host Nation ViewNo binding Code of Conduct on the South China Sea will be finalized under the ASEAN chairship of the Philippines, Foreign Affairs Secretary Theresa Lazaro said
Read on ABS-CBN News →
[7]United News of BangladeshRegional and International ObserversChina, ASEAN make progress on South China Sea pact but miss year-end deadline
Read on United News of Bangladesh →
More in News & Politics
See all →UN Diplomacy
North Korea Rejects UN Dialogue Push and Accuses Secretary-General of Border Bias
5 sources
Eastern Mediterranean
Egypt, UAE and Bahrain Join Greece in UN Condemnation of Turkey-Libya Maritime Pact
8 sources
Diplomatic Expulsions
Austria Expels Four Russian Diplomats Over Alleged Espionage Activities
3 sources
International Law
How Uti Possidetis Juris Converts Internal Administrative Lines Into Sovereign Borders
5 sources
Comments
Every angle. Every day.
Get News & Politics stories with full source coverage and perspective breakdowns, free every day.




